The very rich have a well-developed strategy for controlling legislation that they don’t want. Obamacare provides a perfect example of how this works. First Defense: Congressional committee chairs simply prevent proposed legislation from ever coming to a vote. Sometimes the general public gets sufficiently riled up that the congress decides they have to do something. This was the case with Obamacare … both President Obama and the general public were pushing for reform. The demand for reform was too great to ignore. Second Defense: Armies of highly skilled corporate lawyers are assigned to “assist” in developing the legislation. The team writing Obamacare consisted of congressional aides (mostly generalists with bachelor’s degrees in some subject) and the lawyer lobbyists with expertise in healthcare. For Obamacare, the corporate lawyers significantly outnumbered the congressional aides. I assume the congressional aides are, for the most part, attempting to develop legislation that will help people. The corporate lawyers’ publicly stated purpose is the same … but their real purpose is to make the bill as complex as possible and to ensure that it has some internal contradictions that will be the basis for future lawsuits. The congressional aides are no match for the lawyers in terms of expertise so the lawyers have a great deal of influence over the details of the bill. The Obamacare bill ended up with somewhat more than 1100 pages. Few if any of the members of congress read the bill before voting on it … they relied upon their aides and their donors to tell them how they should vote. Third Defense: The corporate lawyers file lawsuits challenging key aspects of the bill. There are, in general, two types of lawsuits: one, based on the bill contradicting itself and two, any place where there might be a constitutional question (either at the state or federal level). Fourth Defense: The lawsuits are designed in part to invalidate key sections of the bill but also to sow doubt in the publics’ mind about the bill. Fifth Defense: The congressional opponents of Obamacare (in this case mainly the Republicans) begin to introduce legislation designed to reverse key sections of the bill. This entire process is exactly what happened (and is still playing out) with Obamacare. The general strategy outlined above is what happens each time the pressure to “do something” gets so great that congress feels it must act. My first observation about this is that it explains why we so seldom get legislation that actually helps the average citizen. My second observation is that a “riled up public” generally focuses on one issue at a time … and we are facing multiple, inter-related crises that need action NOW. My final observation is that our government is incapable of dealing with the complex of multiple, inter-related crises threatening us. Tinkering around the edges with reforms like term limits will not be adequate. We need a government that is 1) insulated from the pressures the very rich normally bring to bear and 2) with the tools, methods, and structures designed to deal with complexity. This means a serious redesign of government along the lines proposed by the Democracy R & D. My next blog will outline what such a government might look like.
sharePublished on Jul 15, 2026, 11:17:17 on blogs at P4US, NewStory. Last updated on Dec 23, 2023, 13:01:46.
To submit your comment, please login first.
Probably the best known examples in the Western world are Piaget’s stages of cognitive development and Kohlberg’s stages of moral development. Ken Wilber (A Brief History of Everything) is probably the most authoritative and most widely respected author in this area. Wilber found about 200 diffe ...
Published on 2022/11/01/17/50/00 by Barry Clemson
Who Will Use Place4us Virtual Community Centers
Barry Clemson March 20, 2025
Introduction
I want to think about who will use Place4Us Virtual Community Centers … what sort of person will be our main user?
A metaphor may be a good place to start … think about carpenters ...
Published on 2025/03/26/17/26/03 by Barry Clemson
The very rich have a well-developed strategy for controlling legislation that they don’t want. Obamacare provides a perfect example of how this works. First Defense: Congressional committee chairs simply prevent proposed legislation from ever coming to a vote. Sometimes the general public ...
Published on 2023/12/23/13/00/21 by Barry Clemson
Rules of Conduct
Search in all VCCs: No Yes
Submit Selected