The purpose of a system is what it does (POSIWID). Since Stafford Beer formulated this foundational statement, a lot of effort has been on designing societal systems that do what their intended purpose is. To a far lesser extent, the statement has been used to determine the purpose of the physiological systems in the physiology of the planetary life-support system (denoted as ELSS).
Questions what the purpose of a river, an ecosystem, a species is are often answered from an anthropocentric or anthropo-egotistict point of view. In the dominating mindset of capitalistic exploitation, questions asked are: What can this river do for us? What ecosystem services can this ecosystem provide to us? What economic value does this species generate for us?
POSIWID provides a non-anthropocentric general perspective to answer this fundamental question of what the purpose of a system is. We can reverse the statement into "What a system does is its purpose" (WASDIIP). By describing what the system does, the purpose can be determined.
The ELSS sustains life in the critical zone, hence this is its purpose. This purpose is totally independent of any observer or anyone who wants something out of the ELSS. Sustaining life was always the purpose of the ELSS since life emerged on Earth. In some time intervals, the ELSS did a better job and sometimes a worse job (e.g., during mass extinctions). But it never had any other purpose and it never will until its end. This is what WASDIIP tells us.
What ever system is embedded in the ELSS, we can use WASDIIP to discover its objective purpose. This applies to, for example, a river, a wetland, a forest, a lion, and so on.
For example, a river does many different things: it transports water, maintains ecologically important benches, wetlands, and floodplains, transports sediments, moves out floodwaters, regulated groundwater levels, and sustains complex freshwater ecosystems. It also provides drinking water to many animals and for many animals is is a major food source. Thus, within the ELSS, rivers have a multi-dimensional purpose completely independent of whether the species Homo sapiens sapiens is around or not.
WASDIIP also informs us what is not the purpose of a system. For example, it is not the purpose of a lion to become the trophy of a hunter, because the hunter destroys the system "lion" to turn it into a trophy. But it never was the purpose of the lion to be a trophy, because that is not what a living lion does. It never was the purpose of a river to transport pollution because that destroys the river as a freshwater ecosystem. Thus, the company that use a river to transport pollution destroys the river system and takes away its inherent purpose.
WASDIIP can be used to discover the purpose for all systems that together constitute the ELSS. The purpose of these systems is the result of hundreds of millions of years of evolution. These systems have been tested under changing climate conditions, passed through many global disasters including extinction events, and have supported the evolution of life. That is the reason why these systems today are extremely resilient and interact with each other to maintain life on Earth.
Understanding the important of the purpose of these system inherently gives the purpose a very high value. The purpose of the systems in the ELSS needs to be protected.
In the context of modern Anthropocentrism, humans have engaged in the reengineering of many of these systems without fully understand the purpose of the systems. They have assigned purposes to these systems based on the benefits they wanted to reap out of them. Human actions have changed the purpose of the systems or completely destroyed them to give them new purposes. Looking at rivers again, it is clear that utilizing a river to generate hydroelectricity eliminates most dimensions of this river's purpose, including the transport of sediments and the support of freshwater ecosystems. Increasing the water flow in an effort to get floodwaters moved out faster takes away the maintenance of ecologically important wetlands and floodplains. Almost all human interference with systems in the ELSS has degraded, eliminated or replaced the purpose of the system.
A doctor who would approach a patient without fully understanding the purpose of the systems (organs) in a body would certainly develop therapies that only partly maintain the often complex multidimensional purpose of each system - to the disadvantage of the patient. Similar to a human body, where the purpose of each organ can only fully be understood by considering the physiology of this body, the purpose of the systems in the ELSS can only be understood considering the planetary physiology and what each system does in this physiological ELSS.
Current practice in environmental assessments does not emphasize sufficiently the importance of maintaining the purpose of the systems that are proposed to be changed. Taking the POSIWID <=> WASDIIP perspective seems to imply that the purpose of the systems needs to remain unchanged if the goal is to safeguard the ELSS. This implies an inherent right of the systems in the ELSS to maintain their inherent purpose expressed in what these systems do, which is comparable to the inherent nature of human rights. I imaging a future where a constitutional global law requires that human actions do not change the purpose of the systems in the ELSS. If such a law can be established and implemented, the safe-guarding of the ELSS would be guaranteed.
We are planning a VCC on Place4Us that will aim to facilitate an economy that meets our needs while safeguarding the Earth's life-support system, and which the welfare of all current and future generations of human and non-human animals depends. This VCC will support the Economy For HUmanity (E4H) initiative, which aims at this new transformed economy.
sharePublished on Oct 13, 2023, 18:53:46 on blogs at P4US, E4H, COPE. Last updated on Oct 13, 2023, 18:50:13.
To submit your comment, please login first.
The purpose of a system is what it does (POSIWID). Since Stafford Beer formulated this foundational statement, a lot of effort has been on designing societal systems that do what their intended purpose is. To a far lesser extent, the statement has been used to determine the purpose of the physiol ...
Published on 2023/10/11/11/24/ by Hans-Peter Plag
György Buzsáki (2022) states that "Perception is what we do." Christof Koch (2019) describes consciousness as "the feeling of life itself." The feeling of life is the result of our perception of the inside and outside worlds combined. Then, what we do is what we feel and what we a ...
Published on 2022/10/12/09/32/00 by Hans-Peter Plag
Barry said a few days ago that the web pages of Place4Us offer too many choices. He claimed that people get confused and don't want to have so many choices.
I agree that young people today live in a world where choices are made for them by algorithms. During the time they spend with their sma ...
Published on by Hans-Peter Plag
In many publication considering the challenges or dangers of AI, the fact that AI can do many things better than humans is the basis for a reasoning that AI might take jobs away from people and increase productivity. This is a fundamentally flawed view on the impact of AI. It is flawed because it ...
Published on 2023/04/11/00/10/00 by Hans-Peter Plag
It's not about what we can do but about what we feel when we do it.
It's not about the poem we write but about what the poem we write does to us.
While Generative Artificial Intelligence tools might write poems that seem to be better than our poems, writing the poem will not create an exp ...
Published on 2023/08/27/10/24/00 by Hans-Peter Plag
Since the last more than 70,000 years after the eruption of the super volcano Toba, humans, or should I say, sapiens? have migrated. In fact, sapiens evolved into the most invasive of the large mammals, the only one found everywhere on the Earth's surface. Sapiens ...
Published on 2025/03/02/19/16/42 by Hans-Peter Plag
There is a myth based on experiments in the 1840ties that a frog would react to rapid changes but not to a slowly warming water. The myth contented that a frog thrown in boiling water would jump out, but a frog sitting in water that slowly is heated up would not jump out ...
Published on 2025/03/08/20/24/02 by Hans-Peter Plag
Rules of Conduct
Search in all VCCs: No Yes
Submit Selected